Showing posts with label Foreign Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Foreign Policy. Show all posts

Friday, January 29, 2010

Neil MacFarquhar, The Media Relations Department of Hizbollah Wishes You A Happy Birthday


Neil MacFarquhar's 2008 The Media Relations Department of Hizbollah Wishes You A Happy Birthday: Unexpected Encounters in the Changing Middle East is a fun jaunt through the contemporary Middle East. MacFarquhar grew up in Libya on an Esso oil company compound before Qaddafi and his eccentricities seized power and booted the Americans. After a fairly elite upbringing--attending Deerfield and Stanford--he was an AP and NYT correspondent in the Middle East mastering Arabic and sloshing around the region encountering Islamists, the Ikhwan, mukhabarat, and men and women yearning for reform and openness. The 359 pages of text delve into a host of topics, even though Israel-Palestine, Algeria, and a few other countries are absent from his narrative. Even though it's a mouthful, the title is one of my favorites besides Brad Simpson's Economists with Guns detailing a sordid relationship between Indonesia and US development machinations and experts.

This isn't a conventional scholarly book and, as such, it's difficult to review its chapters apart from their journalistic bent. I'm impressed with MacFarquhar's ability to marry anecdotes and interviews with trenchant criticism. He relegates the bulk of his pique to the repressive regimes in the Middle East and the young leaders whose initial burst of promise faded rapidly and was replaced with the iron fist of the state, even if it was wrapped in a new, softer velvet glove. With contacts across the region, he stocked the book with revelatory chapters that portray a vibrant amalgam of people who seek the chance to provide opportunity to women, poor, and the working-class.

All of this serves another purpose in his epilogue, where he offers policy prescriptions to improve America's poor standing in most Arab speaking countries. Among several meaningful suggestions, one of the most salient is his encouragement for Americans to listen to the people he depicts, for they offer keys to grasping the intricacies of each country's unique challenges and hope for the future. In fact, he rejects the idea that technology's rosy potential isn't the US' greatest trait to share. On the last page he states "I would argue that there is an even more powerful export that has been uniquely American for decades. It is an export that no other country has been able to duplicate, and cheap knock-offs just don't exist. That export is hope" (359). If there was a contest, "hope" could win in spades as the single over-used word in 2008.

As I read the book, my mind drifted to an annoyance I've had with speaking on the contemporary Middle East among scholars, graduate students, or those who shun facile stereotypes. They are gun shy when the question shifts to criticizing Islam, Muslims, or regimes in the Middle East. I'm guilty of hemming and hawing when this topic arises, more often than not in reply to someone who proposes an essentialist vision of Islam as repressive, backwards, totalizing, and ancient. It's difficult to strike a balance when discussions meander toward Islam, terrorism, or foreign policy. Most people can't appreciate nuance, won't commit to understanding the faith, and are willing to generalize when it comes to Muslims from Morocco to Malaysia. The fact of the matter, as MacFarquhar points out, is that some people use Islam to preach a message of intolerance that enables or is manipulated to justify repression. One could easily retort with questions of normative behavior, Western cultural mores, Horky and Adorno, etc. One of MacFarquhar's strengths lies in his even-handed resolution to this dilemma by distancing Islam as the thorn in the side of development or freedom while still pointing out that it can be and is fashioned to oppress. Yet the faith also instills confidence in its adherents that an alternate, equitable vision of the future and society is feasible.

All in all, it's a fun book to read that opens a door to a Middle East that I don't know. Unlike hacks writing on the state of the region and directions for US foreign policy, he speaks Arabic fluently and has a insightful awareness of social and cultural currents across a wide spectrum of countries. There are a couple of chapters that an editor could have eviscerated. Despite its length and few a throw-away chapters, it's an impressive account and worth reading if you're inspired by human rights or desire to grasp the modern Middle East outside of the media drum beat of war, intolerance, and terrorism.

Sunday, January 17, 2010

The National Security Archive Blog

For those serious about declassification and research, feast your eyes upon the National Security Archive's blog Unredacted. Unredacted offers news on government secrecy, tips for filing and pursuing pesky Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) requests, as well as strategies to wind through the maze of accessing classified documents. For instance, here's a diagram breaking down the FOIA process, step by step. A neat blog worth your time if this sort of jazz tickles your fancy.

For those who are unaware of this organization, the National Security Archive is not a government agency or publication arm. Instead, the National Security Archive is staffed with academics, lawyers, and journalists based out of George Washington University. They rely on prodigious researchers and are not afraid to use their rights to documents with FOIA requests and lawsuits to confront government secrecy. Working on historic and contemporary issues, the National Security Archive is a conduit of knowledge and, in my opinion, unparalleled in their accomplishments.

Monday, January 11, 2010

China's Rising Power and Workers Abroad

In a recent story in the NYT titled "China's Export of Labor Faces Scorn" in the Uneasy Engagement series, reporters examined China's policy of filling foreign commercial and industrial ventures with its own workers. In Asia, Africa, and the Middle East (notably in Iraq), state-owned and independent enterprises draw on China's elastic labor pool rather than hiring local workers. Countries that suffer from endemic unemployment feel the sting of this policy and it fosters resentment. Of course, with a labor glut, the Chinese government can insist on employing Chinese laborers and easily deport workers and replace them with little difficulty. It's a resourceful strategy to limit labor unrest that threatens production or, in many cases, extraction. China does not deserve a free pass. Its drive centers on natural resource extraction and neoliberal capitalism, which is no better than previous imperial dalliances.

Historically speaking the treatment of indigenous workers by colonial authorities--or how they were shaped by colonial dictates on labor--facilitated the birth of a vibrant and organized working-class in many parts of the world. That working-class rallied its members to oppose colonialism and laid claim to independence politics in the twentieth century. One can question the effectiveness of working-class resistance to a colonial power if they do not have the advantage of acting within the workplace. In other words, without presence in centers of industry and production, strikes and other forms of protest lose their power in crucial ways. At the dawn of a new empire, it's fascinating to analyze how China approaches the working-class and natural resources in developing countries as it speeds expansion.

(This post was written before I left for holiday travel and I'm publishing it today as part of a blogging blitz.)

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

China Digs into a Lucrative Afghan Copper Mine

China was awarded a contract over the Aynak copper mine, and, predictably, the selection contributes to the chorus of graft complaints in China. The Chinese state owned company, China Metallurgical (MCC), beat American and Canadian companies in the 2007 bidding process. The story is back in the news as the mine is preparing to open and conduct extraction. The United States' war enabled this process, and I wouldn't ever contend that we are "owed" first rights to strip a country's national resources. I wanted to post this to illustrate how China's rising is tied with resources and the US's sacrifices, as I pointed out in Trading Sanctions for a Missile Shield.

The Chinese are adept capitalists and most likely its resource diplomacy will run aground and increase disenchantment with China's growing power, as it already has for Iraqi oil workers. The Chinese favor importing their own workers instead of relying on indigenous workers, as the Newsday and NYT articles claim, which can only add to doubts over China's extractive efforts. US's companies record on exploiting local workers is hardly sterling, and the level of US companies' benefits to foreign workers and their environment is debatable. However, the Chinese strategy of avoiding labor strife and discontent by employing Chinese workers in foreign ventures could possibly backfire and foster nationalist resentment toward China and its businesses that seem intent on mining, drilling, or otherwise removing natural resources.

Saturday, October 10, 2009

Winning the Nobel and Renewed Faith in the US


I am proud that our president received the Nobel Peace Prize. Like everyone else, I do not believe that his actions so far merited the award. Obama does not deserve the enmity directed at him by select Republicans and members of the conservative media junta. I doubt Obama wanted this now or at any time in his presidency. Politically, it's a wonderful honor, but a sticky one that carries positives and negatives.

Nevertheless, as I flipped through various news stories, I couldn't help but think that saying "he didn't deserve it yet" sees this from a limited perspective. I think we, as Americans, need to be clear on a few characteristics of the US's role in the world. Our country engaged/engages in unnecessary wars and has put its economic and social interests above those of every other country in the world. The developing world suffered disproportionately and continues to bear a greater burden as legacies of colonialism and neocolonialism hinder growth and peace.

With that being said, it would be foolish to not recognize the US's impressive power and basic fact that the US piloted the Western world through a long period of peace, stability, and prosperity. Despite prickly relations with France at points and several other states, since entering the Second World War, the US assumed and was invited to adopt a leading position in the world. I'm dismayed whenever I hear people claim that the US should remove all of its troops abroad and focus solely on the US. Rejecting a history of American responsibility as a global hegemon (imposed and invited) is dangerous and blind to the nature of international relations. Does that imply that the US should persist in supporting policies that magnify suffering? No, not at all and we as a country could do much more to alleviate hunger, war, etc. Still, it's an imperfect system with players who consistently attempt to one-up other states for material gain. As I mentioned in my reviews of John Perkins' books, there is no proof that an equitable set of global affairs or states will replace a receding US.

Quite possibly, the Nobel committee and certain states have restored faith in the United States to lead, and the peace prize should not be seen as a testament to what he has accomplished, rather his potential as well as renewal of faith in the United States. I think it's disingenuous to believe that the award was given as a reflection on Obama's score card and not as a hope to encourage the president on the part of the committee. Of course, one could discuss ideas of Western normative modernity and what the award represents from a handful of Scandinavian lefties.

Certainly he's not George Bush, however, I think it's simplistic to say that he received the award for simply not being Bush. All the political bluster of a year ago aside, John McCain wouldn't have been Bush. Would the Nobel committee have selected McCain? Unlikely. Obama reached out to the world in a fashion that many presidents never attempted, especially in such a narrow window. His early diplomatic efforts that occurred from the nomination in February until the voting in September should be praised. Still, it puts the onus on him to generate results from his initial successes. Although the Nobel bolsters the diplomacy of the past few months, it lands at an ironic time as the White House contemplates increasing troop levels. So Obama has to earn it and persevere regardless of Afghanistan. Even Michael Moore encourages the president to earn the award. It will be tricky, but I believe he won't languish and it's counterproductive for the US's stature to wish that he fails.

Monday, October 5, 2009

John Perkins' Confessions of an Economic Hit Man and the Secret History of The American Empire




















Shortly after they were published, I wanted to read John Perkins' books recounting his past as an economic hit man. We flew to Rhode Island for a wedding this weekend, and I took the opportunity to check the books out from the DPL. Confessions (2004) and Secret History (2007) offer insight into Perkins' past as an economic hit man. In short, he believes that the NSA or another shadowy government organization guaranteed his employment and training to build an economic empire for the US and to create massive networks of debt and economic subservience for the third world. In fact, the latter is not difficult to believe. I question whether he received some form of government training through a mysterious, vanishing woman named Claudine. To me, it strains credulity and introduces a conspiratorial element that I doubt and he cannot support outside of his reminiscences.

As I read Confessions, I kept thinking of James Frey's A Million Little Pieces. I do not question if Perkins participated in a process of economic warfare for private sector gain, rather if he received orders to carry the weight of empire building. Could he realize it well after the fact and express remorse for his actions? Certainly, and it appears that one of his motives for writing the book was to expose the sordid tale of American economic policies since the 1970s that produced little wealth for few except those in key positions in the private sector.

After reading Confessions, I was curious if Secret History departed from the script he laid out in his first book and contributed a new level of analysis. Secret History reeks of an author who pumps out a second book to build on the success of the previous work while providing stale insight. It continues his travelogue of rape and pillage capitalism with more sex, exotic locations and people, and dubious historic claims. His vision of American history is cloudy and, at times, wrong. He embraces the mythology of the Revolution for the purposes of drawing a distinction between his utopian vision of government and the current nature of domestic and international policy. I don't know where or how he settled on the conclusion that President Dwight Eisenhower acquiesced to anyone to oppose the British, French, and Israeli aggression against Israel. The transparent historical record disproves that wild-eyed claim, as well as others on the Middle East. (We never invaded Iraq twice, which he struggles understanding.) Then there's his prose and structure. The book is clunking and poorly edited. For instance: it's disdain not distain as he uses it; one loses a job, not looses; scorporatocracy is not a word, whereas corporatocracy is. Those three examples are the ones that I noted, but the book was not limited to those few instances. Too many chapters are inchoate missives that often fail to offer more than glimpses of ideas without fully developing them or tying them in a cogent manner to larger themes.

One of my primary complaints is that there's a larger question he nearly touches, but neglects to address. For all his pleading to reform American business practices and international capitalism, he doesn't propose an alternate vision that will improve the plight of developing countries. Is it feasible to reform American corporations while allowing them to maintain their hegemony? My guess is no, which begs the question of who or what will replace our titans of capitalism? The US launched a global campaign at the turn of the 19th century to spread its version of commerce and business arrangements, and I doubt anyone would say that the mission was a failure. In fact, one could argue that the story of the 20th century is how American policy makers convinced the rest of the world to adopt its economic structures and order. Due to that, however, it's foolish to believe that weakening American companies to make them less profit oriented would convince similar entities to pursue the same strategy. Capitalism is a no holds barred game and reforming the Americans doesn't guarantee that Chinese or another state's corporations won't take advantage of weakness and exploit the channels dug by Bechtel, Halliburton, etc. If Perkins wants to recast the function as well as form of the US business and economic practices, I applaud his efforts, no matter how fruitless I find them. I simply would not turn to his books as guides.

Thursday, October 1, 2009

Juan Cole's Top Misconceptions on Iran

Juan Cole is one of the most reliable and prominent bloggers on Middle Eastern politics. His purpose remains to dispel ideas on the Middle East, Arabs, Islam, and their danger to Americans. His recent post, top things you think you know about Iran that are not true, offers several pointed examples of false ideas on Iran that are propagated in the US. Here are two of my favorites:

Belief: Iran is aggressive and has threatened to attack Israel, its neighbors or the US

Reality: Iran has not launched an aggressive war modern history (unlike the US or Israel), and its leaders have a doctrine of "no first strike." This is true of Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, as well as of Revolutionary Guards commanders.

and

Belief: Isn't the Iranian regime irrational and crazed, so that a doctrine of mutally assured destruction just would not work with them?

Actuality: Iranian politicians are rational actors. If they were madmen, why haven't they invaded any of their neighbors? Saddam Hussein of Iraq invaded both Iran and Kuwait. Israel invaded its neighbors more than once. In contrast, Iran has not started any wars. Demonizing people by calling them unbalanced is an old propaganda trick. The US elite was once unalterably opposed to China having nuclear science because they believed the Chinese are intrinsically irrational. This kind of talk is a form of racism.

Saturday, September 26, 2009

Trading a Missile Shield for Sanctions

Obama launched an eager push at the United Nations and at the G-20 gathering in Pittsburgh to foster international resolve on punishing Iran for its nuclear energy and purported nuclear weapon program. Even though US intelligence failed to locate any evidence of a weapons program, the disclosure of a new uranium enrichment facility in Qom scares the bejesus out of the Americans, British, French, and Israelis. As Juan Cole points out, however, the Qom installation is suspicious but should not be regarded as a sure sign of a nuclear weapons program. Nor should it it swell the drum beats for war. At Foreign Policy, Marc Lynch believes that the Obama administration engineered a successful first diplomatic strike at the UN and in Pittsburgh that will fast-track sanctions or other international efforts to dismantle Iran's quickening pace. A WINEP fellow and FP Shadow Government contributor, Michael Singh, offers guarded praise for the initial efforts. Despite some sun, he forecasts red skies at morning if Obama and the US' allies cannot rein in Iran over the course of the next few months.

If Obama can draw Russia into agreement on imposing new sanctions, then he plucked a thorn from the bear's paw and demonstrated why an effective diplomatic agenda requires compromise over issues that threaten your dancing partner. (As an aside, my friend Nate Matlock commented that I could have been more explicit in the thorn post. Poland and the Czech Republic are NATO member countries and thus are shielded by a collective security agreement and have little to fear from a direct Russian attack. Thanks, Nate.) The question centers on China's support or rejection of the American, British, French, and Israeli movement. After the tire tariff, the US and China are in a minor spat with President Hu Jintao voicing his displeasure with the US trade decision. The Daily Beast's Mark McKinnon--a self-avowed free market and radical free trader--is fretting over the Obama administration's precedent and worries that an impending trade war will result from Obama's bows to scary big labor. Oh, you innocent free traders. Similar to those who apotheosize neoliberal free trade, McKinnon attacks organized labor (how can we shackle the free market? do you hate freedom?) and neglects to shed light on Chinese policies that might disagree with his unblemished ideals of free and fair competition. I've stated my opinions on these utopian flights of fancy, so I won't beat a dead horse.

The Obama administration will need to organize an effective diplomatic coalition in the P5 if they don't want the Chinese to veto sanctions. The Chinese are unlikely to jump on board without some inducement or pressure. Gal Luft, writing for the Harvard Middle East Strategy blog, suggests that the Chinese won't be plied away easily as they stand to gain from a proposed natural gas pipeline named Nabucco. Even though I'm not wild on his political views, Luft's writing on energy are fantastic. The Chinese have demonstrated their keen aptitude in natural resource diplomacy and leveraging their resources. (McKinnon and his orthodox pals don't seem to register any indignation with Chinese actions in such cases, apparently. But that Employee Free Choice Act, it's a sure sign of economic ruin.) Luft's cautionary rhetoric aside, he delineates the steps the US should take to prevent the pipeline from crossing Pakistan into India and through to China. It's worth questioning if the US has the power to accomplish that goal as its position in Afghanistan grows more precarious by the day, and it's worth wondering if the US can convince the Pakistanis--and by extension India and China--that it's not in their vested interest to push for the pipeline. (Luft says no in an August FP piece on the foolishness of gas sanctions for Iran.) We're entering a new, exciting period of resource diplomacy, and energy concerns will assume a center spot in any discussion on sanctions over Iran's nuclear program and if President Obama can swing President Hu onto the bandwagon.

Wednesday, September 23, 2009

Tire Tariff and Free Trade, Neoliberal Economics

The steelworkers union scored a coup recently with the tariff on Chinese tires, and the United Steelworkers have a large appetite for leveling imbalances in the facade of free trade. Pointing out that Chinese companies receive lucrative subsidies and a host of state support, the steelworkers convinced the commerce department and the executive branch to place a thirty-five percent tax on Chinese tires. Obama recognizes that, in some ways, he owes his victory to unions and if he wants to win in Ohio and Pennsylvania, he will back their requests. As United Steelworkers president Leo Gerard pointed out, Chinese companies benefit from state intervention and support. To further illustrate this point, the final installment in the NYT's series Uneasy Engagement--which reports on the "stresses and strains of China’s emergence as a global power"--found that state companies and corporations headed by influential politicians or their relatives were linked to corrupt business tactics in Africa. Far from relying on fair strategies, the Chinese government and its businesses (the same as the Americans and most world powers) utilizes its leverage and financial resources to enrich itself and state companies regardless of the cost. It's silly to believe that they play the game with any other intention.

As one could guess, economists are decrying the tariff and warning of protectionism battles that threaten the inviolable doctrine of free trade. It's all well and good if you're preaching free trade in an economics classroom or from an executive's chair in a conference room, but the utopia of neoliberal free trade doesn't pay off for millions of Americans and hundreds of millions more across the world. My complaint about macroeconomics is that they fail to address the social cost and how free trade can eviscerate the working-class. Recently, in Paul Krugman's piece in the NYT Magazine, How did Economists Get it So Wrong, he blasted macro econ profs for, ultimately, their ignorance and reliance upon faulty quantitative models that distanced economists in academia, government, and the private sector from reality. While it won't surprise anyone, he lumps the majority of blame on neoclassical economists from the University of Chicago school ("freshwater economists") who dismissed Keynesian economics roundly. (As an aside, in a blog entry on Conscience of a Liberal, Krugman shares that Chicago economists did not enjoy his jeremiad. In typical fashion, Krugman doesn't give a rat's ass.)

Krugman credits the saltwater economists--the camp which he falls in as well as Brad DeLong--for keeping the Keynesian flame alive, and he advocates for dropping byzantine Planglossian modeling and a shift toward behavioral economics to grasp how and why economists function. Behavioral economics might offer a path to reduce volatility and put a necessary end to dreamy concepts such as credit derivative swaps.

I'm not an economist and I don't play one on TV or popular press outlets. I agree with Krugman and I think he's correct for pointing out that the profession as a whole requires an intellectual overhaul. However, his article never mentions how people encounter the Great Recession and similar horrific contractions. People appear as abstract, generalized concepts rather than individuals who suffer, lose, or marginally benefit. Economists are divorced from social consequences, which is why I'm pleased that the Obama administration acted in concert with the Steelworkers' requests. The obvious rejoinder is that macro economic methodology doesn't permit for such a narrow focus, which is the preserve of micro economics or social scientists. Fine, but it fails to explain why America's leading economists advance theory and policy that benefit a small section of a population and neglects to help the majority of people and often hurts them in pursuit of lofty ideas of streamlined free trade and GDP increases.

The question returns to a simple inquiry: who benefits and at what cost?

Thursday, September 17, 2009

Pulling the Thorn from the Bear's Paw: Terminating the Eastern Europe Missile Shield

The Obama administration announced today that it is formally ending the Eastern Europe anti-ballistic missile shield with planned installations in the Czech Republic and Poland to intercept potential Iranian missiles. According to the NYT, the administration will base missiles in Turkey and in seaborne craft after recent intelligence indicated that the Iranian government chose to develop short-range and intermediate missiles rather than long-range missiles.

This story first appeared a couple of weeks ago, so it's not terribly surprising. Even though this policy correction will please Putin and Medvedev, it sends a clear signal to Ukraine, Georgia, the Czech Republic, and Poland that the US is placing it's national security priorities higher than the fears of a new iron curtain, even in the wake of last year's Georgian/South Ossetia conflict. However, it's doubtful that the Obama administration is leaving these states high and dry without any arms or potential security commitments.

Nordin Top Dead?

Another report from Indonesia that police killed Nordin M. Top last night. The national police chief referred to his death as a Ramadan blessing. It's a relief for the US after the raid in Somalia that resulted in the death of Saleh Ali Saleh Nabhan.

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Is HRC Revolutionizing American Foreign Policy?

Secretary of State Clinton is a lightning rod for criticism and praise as she commandeers the levers of US foreign policy. She's now seven months into the job and some are starting to score her work so far. If there was an A++, David Rothkopf would assign HRC such a lofty grade. Leaving little to the imagination, Rothkopf writes that she's quietly revolutionizing foreign policy. I like Secretary Clinton, and her choice of Anne-Marie Slaughter was impressive. When I read the article on Sunday, however, I rolled my eyes at his saccharine review of her first few months at State. He's correct on several points, especially how the media focuses on her attire and attitude rather than some of her accomplishments. I'm troubled by several elements of his article. Notably, I don't believe that the Obama administration is reinventing the diplomacy wheel, regardless of how well I think HRC might be performing. Rothkopf isn't winning me or a variety of people as fans when he praises this strategy: "In the same vein, she has opened up Cuba to American telecommunications companies and reached out to India's private sector on energy cooperation -- showing that this administration will seek to advance national interests by tapping the self-interests of the business community." ETA: On Monday, Rothkopf participated in a chat based on his article. You can read the transcript here.

From the other side of the aisle, enterprising Christian Brose obliterates Rothkopf for his head in the sand stance on the Bush administration's foreign policy. Writing on the blog Shadow Government at ForeignPolicy.com, Brose sinks his canines into Rothkopf's millennial article. In an appropriately titled post (What is David Rothkopf Smoking?) Brose picks apart the paen to Hillary and, with sufficient evidence, demonstrates how the Obama administration is in part picking up where Bush and Rice left off. (Of course, one could say that Bush utilized networks Clinton created, and Clinton capitalized on the Bush I admin's work at the end of the Cold War...but that could be a stretch.) With Bush and Rice, the US led the way on significant multilateral efforts to bridge the gap between the United States' long-term waning power and what Fareed Zakaria dubbed the "rise of the rest." It would be disingenuous to ignore the Bushies' accomplishments, some of which Bose helped foster.

In the closing paragraphs, he questions whether Obama and Secretary Clinton will elicit more progress than Bush due to the nature of international politics consisting of nation-states who fervently press their own interests over neighbors or allies. And while he's got a point, the administration he worked under embarked on those initiatives after thumbing their nose at world opinion, and there's room to question how seriously the folks on Pennsylvania Avenue and in Foggy Bottom took multilateral or UN endeavors to broker peace or prosperity abroad. Possibly Bush and Rice helped to create the scaffolding for a multipolar direction of US policy in the future. Nevertheless, they didn't do much to strengthen the foundation and accomplish lasting improvements thanks to the militaristic thrust of US diplomacy under Bush. No one wanted to and few could work with Bush, which was the product of the Bush administration's demeanor and not the zero-sum game that is international affairs. When one of your biggest fans is Mikheil Saakashvili, you've got problems.

It's too early to pass judgment on the Obama administration's diplomacy. It's obvious that contradictions exist as well as legacies from the Bushies persist despite Obama's and HRC's out with the old rhetoric. And what Bose neglects to discuss is how State suffered losses to the Pentagon, and it appears that the Obama administration is returning (albeit slower than I would prefer) the rightful control of diplomacy to the professionals and not the generals, as even Defense Secretary Gates proposed. So where are we?

Saturday, August 8, 2009

Reviews of Naomi Klein The Shock Doctrine and Jon Jeter Flat Broke in the Free Market

(mea culpa: I can't always guarantee that these reviews, or any post for that matter, will be written to the best of my abilities.)

Naomi Klein,
The Shock Doctrine: Rise of Disaster Capitalism, 2007.

Jon Jeter, Flat Broke in the Free Market: How Globalization Fleeced Working People, 2009.

When Kate and I traipsed around Ecuador and Peru on our ill-fated honeymoon, I recall a conversation we had in
Puno, Peru. Our trips aren't extravagant and our accommodations usually fall on the bottom scale of the budget traveler. (Of course, one could say that decisions such as that lead one to contract a nasty stomach illness that can effectively ruin a honeymoon.) Anyway, we pondered whether we helped or hurt with our travel. After rolling through the vapid glitz of Lima and taking several tourist trips, we both questioned the nature of our travel. For me, it was an issue that bothered me on another level as I helped a company outsource segments of its business. (For the record, the owner of the company has kept Kate and I eating and paying rent and my boss has been incredibly generous to me for the past six years.)

Naomi Klein's weighty book tackles some of these various issues. Clocking in at 460 pages, it's a commitment as she takes you through the battlefields of neoliberalism that left various third world economies cratered and reeling. The Shock Doctrine is exhaustive, to the point that this reviewer was forced to skim at an accelerated pace to conquer the often unskimmable paragraphs. I wanted to enjoy this book. If one of her goals was to chronicle the abuses stemming from the imposition of neoliberal economic development, then she succeeded handily. Nevertheless, I have problems with her use of terminology (especially the term corporatist), the relative absence of the US labor movement and working-class, and her proclivity for marrying the concepts of physical torture (electro shock) with economic counterrevolution (Milton Friedman’s “shock treatment”).

I'm no acolyte of Milton Friedman, and I feel that if you don't question the Friedmanite primacy given to markets then you're not paying attention. That being said,
Milton Friedman nor, I would argue, the Chicago Boys convinced a military thug such as Pinochet and others to unleash harsh waves of terror. Possibly the US government did, but that blurs the line of agency and the documentary record on these subjects tends to portray the US as players who acquiesced from the sidelines. (The CIA records aren’t released and I’m not in the business of speculating. Al McCoy is better suited for that task.) She could be stronger if she imposed a clearer vision of corporatism and painted less of a relationship between torture and economic shock therapy. She strays from the torture-shock treatment analogy as she progresses through the book, nevertheless, I think it's a flawed premise. Can't one say that communist revolutions or counterrevolutions imposed economic systems that proved equally as disastrous? The answer is yes, and she legitimizes that line of argumentation. Then the question revolves around revolutions and economics.

If that's the problematic aspect, Klein's clear strength lies in charting how neoliberalism failed to lift all boats. Those who benefited remain the developed states and multi-national corporations. Starting with Richard Nixon, neoliberalism became a pillar of American foreign policy where it remains to this day. We associate market freedom with political freedom, and, as she points out, that logic is severely flawed. This book isn't for beginners, however, and I wouldn't recommend it unless someone had a passionate interest in comprehending the economic beliefs that hobbled developing countries and peoples and led us to this current economic malaise.

Jon Jeter's thinner and equally interesting Flat Broke in the Free Market picks apart neoliberalism from a different methodological stance. Jeter traveled to Africa, Latin America, and in the US interviewing those who toil under neoliberalism's false promises to illustrate how working-class folk suffer under the weight of neoliberalism at home and abroad. The interviews provide a fascinating texture that Klein often overlooks, which is understandable. Beginning with a story of a Kenyan woman whose daily life seems to mirror Alexander Solzhenitsyn's One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich as the woman tries to sell tomatoes in a desperate bid to survive and feed her children.

Jeter's interviews span the working-class spectrum, everything from the aforementioned tomato seller to prostitutes in Latin America to the folks in the urban renewal group Imagine Englewood If. They allow him to paint the stunning, yet desolate, experiences of the poor that point to no signs of bettering any time soon. Many of the struggles gravitate toward basic necessities--water, safety/security, food, shelter--and work. Not to trivialize his book, but his dedication is one of the more touching ones I've read in this literature. He dedicates the book to those poor who desire to see the ocean. I can't do it justice here, so I won't try and you'll have to trust me on this one.

What would a review be without criticism? First, his fawning praise of Hugo Chavez at the book's close seems romantic and utopian. Second, Asia and Europe are completely absent. Nevertheless, a work can't do everything and I think it's a minor quibble. Third, often his analysis is lost in the midst of the stories and the reader often has to unpack some of what he might try to argue. Fourth, who's responsible here? Who are the agents? Often the guilty parties are Western companies and the US government that employ a neoliberal framework. I think it's
dubious to not judge states as sharing the blame for leveling their countries' economies and social structures, but they largely are absent as players who make the decisions. Even though the economic aspect does, as Jeter maintains, demonstrate a new lever of neocolonialism, I find his treatment of agency and responsibility slippery and sloppy.

So what? What do these books tell us? I guarantee that read back-to-back Klein and Jeter don't line one up for an uplifting experience. The culprit remains Friedman and his obsession with free markets that Western governments pushed since the early 1970s, with the clear victim being those in the US and the poor spread out in the world. What can be done? After finishing these two books I have my doubts if this edifice (with such considerable scaffolding in academia, government, and the private sector) can be demolished. This month's Adbusters addresses these questions. Still, I am uncertain if an equitable form of trade and economics will arise from our current economic contraction. Is there a way out of neoliberalism? I hope so, because as both of these books reveal, far too many people suffer for an economic ideology that benefits so few.

Friday, August 7, 2009

Hillary's Chortle over John Bolton

John Bolton trashed Bill Clinton's successful trip to free Laura Ling Euna Lee, like most of Fox News.

Here's a snippet of Bolton's acute mind that devalues Clinton's and the Obama Administration's victory


Here's Hillary's Response starting at 26 seconds

Baitullah Mehsud Killed by a Predator Strike

It was heavily rumored in news outlets yesterday, Baitullah Mehsud was killed on Wednesday in a reported attack that killed his wife. After some initial confusion, the Pakistani Taliban announced Mehsud is dead. So what does this mean? Is this a win for the US strategy of drone attacks that spiked after Obama assumed office?

As Juan Cole opined this morning, Mehsud was a mass murder and a thug, and the world of arts and leisure won't miss him. Cole asks the pertinent question on the results of his death. It seems likely that another thug will replace Mehsud, but one should ask whether this is a victory for the US strategy of disrupting command and control. Cole maintains that political solutions offer the only true ways to disarm and defang an insurgency, and assassinations won't turn the tide. That being said, I'm sure there are some happy folks in Northern Virginia.

Wednesday, July 22, 2009

Monday, July 20, 2009

Those Arabs and Their Shoes

Yesterday's NYT featured an article on pilgrimages in Iraq and the death of five Iraqis, which is considered a relative success. Juan Cole dubbed it a big win for Obama and his attempt to withdraw the bulk of American forces from Iraq in a peaceful fashion. The annoying part is the accompanying photo: a pile of shoes - the continuing obsession we have with Arab shoes. One could say that it represents a mass of people. On the other hand, one could easily comment that it reveals the dearth of understanding of the Arab world (or Muslims, for that matter), ritual purity, as well as a realiance on facile assumptions that sell well.


If American churches were depicted solely by the parking lots (be they filled or empty), people would howl about the misrepresentation. What's wrong with examining the abundance of cars and naked consumerism devoid of any context or links to the issues at hand?




In other news, the NYT also ran a brief story on Shabab's troubled finances and their turn to kidnapping in attempt to finance their resistance operations. The US dropped forty tons of weapons and ammunition into the Islamic Courts Union government's hands in June.

Thursday, July 16, 2009

The CIA and the Super Spook Fantasy

Films condition how we interpret culture and society. Movies can open new doors to how we visualize foreign cultures, even though they have a tendency to portray them falsely as oriental or exotic. In American film and popular conception, the CIA and similar intelligence services often are depicted as omnipotent agencies staffed with brilliant and deadly spies who traverse cultures, languages, and geographies with little hesitation as they flip through their multiple passports, currencies, and dialects. The recent flap over secret CIA assassination teams points to another reality: the CIA couldn't manage the logistics and implementation. The CIA is powerful and can wield a tremendous influence abroad. Nevertheless, analysts and agents are people with normal limitations.

Thursday, July 9, 2009

Andrew Bacevich, COIN, and the Direction of US Warfare in Afghanistan and Beyond

Think tanks and administrations have a traditionally porous border, which in and of itself isn't too surprising considering the nature of policy experts in think tanks such as Heritage, Cato, Brookings, Council on Foreign Relations, and the newly formed Center for a New American Security. CNAS, formed in 2007, is picking up some of my favorite bloggers and assembling them into an exciting institution: Abu Muqawama and now they poached Marc Lynch from foreign policy. They've assembled a fine list of experts and academics in this fledgling organization that has sent its members to the Obama administration. CNAS is known for fancying counter insurgency (COIN) theory and warfare as it plays out in the laboratories of Iraq and Afghanistan, and focuses on Asia and the Middle East. I'm curious to see what they produce and if they can survive in the long-term.

As one could expect, Andrew Bacevich, one of favorite contemporary thinkers and historians, is moving in similar circles even though his message rejects the Bush and Obama administrations' diplomacy and direction, and he seems wary of any approach that treats COIN as a panacea. Rob at Arabic Media Shack condensed Bacevich's recent LAT op-ed "Obama's Strategic Blind Spot" and his several points that center on one aspect: there is no change in strategy, rather one in tactics that avoids reevaluating America's role in the world. Bacevich's "Best Intentions: An Appreciation of Graham Greene" in World Affairs is also enlightening, sharp read. According to the folks at The American Conservative, Bacevich's recent talk at a CNAS event leveled the crowd with the lack of his triumphalist COIN glossolalia and his advice that the US should lessen its international prominence. As you can guess, he apparently was the contrarian who spoke uncomfortable truths that didn't jive with the tenor of previous discussions on how COIN is going to save the world. I should mention that I have some doubts about TAC's reporting and how their bias influencs their conclusions on CNAS considering they exist on opposite sides of the political aisle.

I don't think of Bacevich as an historian who mines archives, sifting through dusty memcons and telcons for the truth of the matter. His works investigate contemporary or recent history. As I've posted before, Bacevich is an acolyte of William Appleman Williams, Charles and Mary Beard, and what is referred to as the Progressive School in foreign policy history and American history. So it was no surprise that Bacevich wrote the introduction to the newest edition of Williams' Tragedy of American Diplomacy. Despite my extreme admiration for Bacevich and his work, I don't know that policy retrenchment or shrinking is the solution nor is it compatible for international affairs. Who will take over the US' role as hegemon? Could chaos ensue? Who is going to guarantee that Wienerschnitzel remains one of the strongest multi-national corporations?

The US needs the world, but the worlds needs the US even if the Bretton Woods order is dead and the American security umbrella is in a poor state. Before Bacevich espoused his grand dream for a conservative (in the true sense of the word) diplomacy and military role, another historian advocated for a similar tack. Michael H. Hunt--emeritus professor of American foreign relations history at the University of North Carolina--rejected American gallavanting in the wake of Vietnam. In an afterword to the newest edition of his classic Ideology and U.S. Foreign Policy, Hunt admits that he was wrong.

The US is not implicated in world affairs in such a deep and complex fashion that a retreat is hard to imagine and if attempted might produce dire consequences overseas, notably a breakdown of global integration, with international anarchy a likely prospect. Moreover, an assertive US nationalism is so important in providing social glue for a diverse, mobile people that a repudiation of the country's leading role on the international stage might well prove deeply divisive at home and spawn bitter cries of betrayal. Finally, pressing domestic problems are now inextricably entangled with international trends and pressures, ranging from climate change to global finance and trade to resource scarcity to immigrant pressures generated by failed states and stagnant economies. (216)
So what are we to do? The US could afford to drop its military adventures, as everyone acknowledges, and it should welcome the rise of a multi-polar world while encouraging allied states and easing immigration standards. In the long run, the US needs a positive birth rate for the country to remain thriving. It's an uneasy fact, but it's true, folks. Diplomacy is a zero-sum game, but that doesn't mean we can't make way for the rise of equal powers, especially if the US wishes to preserve a legacy of its worldview even if there are serious contradictions and dilemmas inherent to neo-liberalism or neo-conservatism.

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

"The only chance we have as a country is for bin Laden to detonate a major weapon in the US"

I thought Michael Scheuer (aka Anonymous and author of Imperial Hubris) had valuable criticisms on US policy and terrorism. Watching this clip of Scheuer on the Glenn Beck show reversed any of those preconceived notions. He's marching to Dick Cheney's tune of hoping the country gets attacked so they can be vindicated and that hateful Obama will fail. Of course, the Bush administration failed when they were needed most: preventing 9/11. Pleading of "they prevented another attack" doesn't pardon them for neglecting their duties.

Anyway, Scheuer is nuts.